Now People Will Think I Stole It

Published by Rick on Tagged Uncategorized

Over the past few weeks, at least five different sources have sent me a link from “Buckshot – The Movie” which shows a clown by the name of Puddles Pity Party singing The Who’s “Pinball Wizard” to the tune of Johnny Cash’s “Folsom Prison Blues.” I’ve gone to where the original link was posted, which has gotten thousands of comments about how damn funny it is. I’d probably think it was funny, too, if I hadn’t been doing the same mash-up for close to 25 Freaking Years!

This is one of those unfortunate circumstances for me, as that link has gotten over Five Million views where my original YouTube video of it struggled to get 1000 when I first posted it five years ago. I run the risk of being accused of stealing the bit if I perform it, the small consolation being that I’m not doing stand-up much anymore. So with my next gig not until June, I wonder if I’d need to do a disclaimer, and if I do that, how many in the audience would believe me.

And such has been the problem from time immemorial in the world of stand-up, or at least as far back as Milton Berle. The bigger name can steal from the lesser-knowns, and get the accolades for something that’s not theirs. There have been notorious joke thieves, and what the fuck, let’s name them, Carlos Mencia and Eddie Griffin for starters, and sorry, but Robin Williams was sued countless times over that offence. Robin would at least get out the check book, while the other two would deny it.  By the way, I can cite instances of all three appropriating bits of mine, but so can just about every US comic I ever knew back in the day. I’ve only heard stories about who the big joke bandits are in UK, so I’ll let them remain anonymous for now.

Back to Pinball/Johnny. I can’t say I fully came up with it myself, as the idea was presented to me in 1991 after a show in New York by someone from the audience. He was not a comic,  but he saw me doing some other Johnny Cash bit, as I’ve done Johnny’s voice since I was about 15. The guy thought the bit was funny (Johnny Cash explaining the Pythagorean Theorem), then said matter-of-factly, “You know Pinball Wizard and Folsom Prison Blues are interchangeable?” I sounded that out in my head, then said, “Do you know you just wrote me about five minutes of material?” He was cool, said he was glad to help. A far cry from some of the people who would come up after a gig with the words, “Hey I got a joke you could use in your act, and I won’t even charge you for it,” only to find the joke is either so perverted, racist or obscure that I’ve had to ask, “And in what part of my act do you think that would have fit?”

Is the bit funny the way these Puddles has done it? Hard for me to say, as I couldn’t watch it all the way through. I have a credo with song parodies that has always worked for me. I’m not Weird Al Yankovic, not blessed with co-writers who can actually make a joke last the entire length of a song, so I have always used more of a hit and run tactic. Most of my parodies were kept to one verse maximum, and in many cases a single line was sufficient. The Johnny/Who song, when I performed it, was just the first verse, but the Puddles version contains the entire song. That’s why I couldn’t watch the whole video, but couldn’t imagine any surprises, unless the clown unleashed some wicked guitar solo that makes Pete Townshend envious. Maybe he does the reverse, which was what I often did, i.e. The Who singing Folsom Prison, complete with Townshend windmills at the end. If Puddles did that, it would only make me madder.

There are a few bits of solace I can get from this clear and present theft. One is that Puddles Pity Party and his associates are far more likely to get sued for copyright infringement by either Pete Townshend or the estate of Johnny Cash than I would.  That would be justice. The other solace is that people tend to forget, so unless  “Buckshot – The Movie” is an across the board smash, the bit will be forgotten soon enough, and I’ll be able to resume doing it. Then again, my stand-up gigs are so few, it may not be worth worrying about, and maybe I’ve just wasted 800+ words.

 

April 29th, 2017



Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.